NEWS
BIX-CK813 vs Ultrasound: Teaching Ascites Assessment

Created on:2026-11-18  |   bomn

Percussion manikin or ultrasound phantom? A comparison of how each teaches ascites assessment, using the BIX-CK813 as the physical reference.

...

BIX-CK813 vs Ultrasound: Teaching Ascites Assessment

BIX-CK813 vs Ultrasound: Teaching Ascites Assessment

Quick answer. The BIX-CK813 is a soft abdominal manikin mounted on a test bench that can rotate the patient left and right, allowing shifting-dullness percussion practice and abdominal puncture in supine, semi-recumbent or lateral positions. Puncture produces a loss-of-resistance sensation and simulated peritoneal fluid can be aspirated; skin and puncture modules are replaceable, with consumables supplied.

Two teaching tools now compete for the same curriculum hours in ascites assessment: the traditional physical-examination trainer, and the ultrasound phantom. They teach different things, and departments often buy one and then complain it does not do the other's job.

What each approach delivers

CriterionPercussion/puncture manikin (BIX-CK813 type)Ultrasound phantom
Core skillShifting dullness, fluid wave, landmark palpation, blind punctureImage acquisition, needle visualisation under guidance
Surface landmarksRib arch edge, xiphoid, rectus, umbilicus, groin, iliac spine and crest — all palpableOften absent; the phantom is a block of tissue
Patient positioningBench rotates the model to simulate lateral decubitus; semi-recumbent possibleUsually fixed
Puncture feedbackLoss of resistance, aspiratable simulated fluidNeedle tip visible on screen
ReusabilityReplaceable skin and puncture modulesReplaceable inserts, often gel
Best fitPhysical diagnosis teaching, blind paracentesisUltrasound-guided paracentesis, residency procedure training

Why the physical trainer still matters

Percussion is a bedside skill that cannot be rescued by an image. A clinician who cannot demonstrate shifting dullness still needs to know when to reach for the probe, and examiners still test the manoeuvre. The CK813 supports the full sequence: inspect, palpate, percuss for dullness, ask the patient to roll, percuss again, and confirm the fluid wave.

Paracentesis training on a physical model also retains value. A simulation-based paracentesis curriculum has been published with a comprehensive procedural structure — indication, consent, landmarking, sterile technique, aspiration and post-procedure care — and that structure works on any adequate model [1]. Where ultrasound is available, handmade and commercial phantoms have been validated for guided puncture practice [2]. The two are complementary, not competing.

For the clinical background students need, reviews of cirrhosis and its complications provide the indications for diagnostic and therapeutic paracentesis, including spontaneous bacterial peritonitis assessment [3]. Teaching the procedure without that context produces technicians, not clinicians.

Using the CK813 well

  1. Landmark drill (5 min). Students identify rib arch, xiphoid, rectus edge, umbilicus, iliac crest before any percussion.
  2. Shifting dullness (10 min). Bench in supine; percuss the flanks, rotate to lateral decubitus, percuss again and explain the change.
  3. Fluid wave (5 min). Two-student technique, with the correct hand placement.
  4. Puncture (15 min). Sterile field, Z-track, loss of resistance, aspiration of simulated fluid.
  5. Complication talk (5 min). Bleeding, infection, bowel injury, persistent leak — and what the model cannot show.

Limits to state openly

  • No real pathology. The model cannot simulate coagulopathy, loculation or a surgical abdomen.
  • No ultrasound compatibility. If your programme teaches image-guided drainage, pair it with a phantom.
  • Consumables. Skin and puncture modules wear. Price them before the purchase, not after.
  • Bench footprint. The frame is substantial; confirm the room and doorway dimensions.

Procurement notes

  • Confirm the bench adjustment range and whether it locks securely during puncture.
  • Ask for the consumable list: skin modules, puncture pads, simulated fluid.
  • Verify the manikin accepts the needle and catheter gauges your unit uses.
  • Factory certification: ISO 9001, ISO 14001 and ISO 45001.

Quotation. Bench dimensions, consumable pricing and lead time for the BIX-CK813 are available from cprwell@adaanatomy.com; state whether you also teach ultrasound-guided drainage so the accessories can be quoted together.

FAQ

Q1. What does the BIX-CK813 simulate? Abdominal percussion findings including shifting dullness, plus abdominal puncture with loss of resistance and simulated peritoneal fluid.

Q2. Can the patient be positioned for lateral decubitus percussion? Yes. The test bench rotates the model left and right, and supports semi-recumbent or lateral positioning for puncture.

Q3. Are the puncture modules replaceable? Yes. Skin and puncture components are replaceable, and consumables are supplied.

Q4. Does it work with ultrasound? It is a physical-examination trainer. For image-guided practice, use a dedicated ultrasound phantom alongside it.

Q5. Which landmarks are palpable? Rib arch edge, xiphoid, rectus muscle edge, umbilicus, groin, iliac spine and iliac crest.

Q6. How much space does it need? The unit is built on a test bench with a frame. Request the footprint and weight before ordering for a small skills room.

Product page: BIX-CK813 vs Ultrasound: Teaching Ascites Assessment — specification, packing data and a quotation request form.

References

  1. Sall D, et al. Paracentesis simulation: a comprehensive approach to procedural education. MedEdPORTAL. 2018;14:10747. doi:10.15766/mep_2374-8265.10747
  2. Huang CT, et al. A feasibility study of a handmade ultrasound-guided phantom for paracentesis. BMC Med Educ. 2024;24:351. doi:10.1186/s12909-024-05339-9
  3. Wilson R, et al. Cirrhosis. Med Clin North Am. 2022;106(3):437–446. doi:10.1016/j.mcna.2021.12.001

For a quotation on the BIX-CK813, or consumable packs, write to cprwell@adaanatomy.com.